Oscar Isaac Thought Timothée Chalamet Portraying Bob Dylan Was 'Really Bad Idea' Until He Heard the Actor Sing

Mar. 15, 2025

Oscar Isaacwas not sold onTimothée ChalametasBob Dylanuntil he heard the actor sing Dylan’s songs.

At the 2024Gotham Awardsin New York City on Monday, Dec. 2, Isaac, 45, took presented Chalamet, 28, andA Complete UnknowndirectorJames Mangoldwith the Visionary Tribute award.

As he recalled working with Chalamet on the 2021 movieDune: Part One, he said Chalamet first told him and costarsJosh Brolinand Steven McKinley Henderson aboutA Complete Unknownwhile they were spending time in Chalamet’s trailer on set.

“He starts telling us about his next project he was working on. A movie with the wonderful director James Mangold about a young Bob Dylan coming to New York in 1961,” recalled Isaac, who once portrayed a folk musician in 1961 New York in the 2013 movieInside Llewyn Davis. “And my first thought, ‘It sounds like a really bad idea.’ I mean, it’s Dylan. It’s the holy of holies for me. It just didn’t sound right.”

“Then Timmy takes out his guitar — not a good sign — and starts playing ‘Girl from the North Country,’ " Isaac added. “Now, this is a song I know deeply, to my core, and Josh, Steven and I, we’re not your average Timmy Chalamet groupies. We’re grizzled movie vets. We’ve seen some s—.”

Edward Norton and Timothée Chalamet in A Complete Unknown.Macall Polay/Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures

Macall Polay/Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Even though Isaac estimated Chalamet “had just started learning the guitar” and how to sing at that time, he felt the actor approached Dylan’s music “not as if he was learning something new but as if he was remembering something he’d always known, just rediscovering it.”

Timothée Chalamet in A Complete Unknown.Macall Polay/Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures

Chalamet has been open aboutspending five years preparingto play Dylan, now 83, in the upcomingA Complete Unknown, which covers Dylan’s early rise to fame and decision to begin playing electric guitars in the mid 1960s.

In Isaac’s estimation, Chalamet and filmmaker Mangold, 60, captured Dylan’s essence in the new movie, which is in theaters Dec. 25.

“James and Timothée have approached this work with a mix of humility and irreverence, just like Dylan approached the Great American Songbook, probing familiar forms to rediscover the truth of the present moment,” Isaac said during his Gotham Awards speech as he brought the filmmaker-actor duo to the stage.

source: people.com